Pre-loved book club · est. 2026

Rescued books, matched to you.

Three hand-picked, pre-loved books a month, wrapped as a surprise. Matched to your taste by a real person (and a very good algorithm), with one wildcard for luck.

$25

a month for three books.
US shipping included.

  • Graded Very Good or better
  • Bad Match Guarantee
  • Skip or pause in two taps

Every stray gets a passport · scan it to see where it’s been No book left behind · unsendable books go to prison libraries & literacy programs Due back: never · it’s yours to keep or pass on Trade in your shelf · earn credit toward your next box
How it works

Four steps from sniff to shelf

Two minutes of questions now, a parcel of surprises every month after.

  1. Take the Sniff Test

    Tell Dewey what you love, what you never want to see again, and how adventurous you’re feeling. Two minutes, no essay questions.

  2. We sniff out your three

    Our matcher shortlists from thousands of rescued books; a human curator checks every box and writes you a note.

  3. Unwrap the surprise

    Each book arrives wrapped in paper with a clue tag. Can’t wait? Peek at the clues online before the postie arrives.

  4. Read, rate, rehome

    Rate each book in tail-wags so next month gets sharper. Keep it, gift it, or trade it back for credit. Its passport follows it.

The full tour, with timings

Not random. Surprising.

Every box is a trio

Pure random is fun for a month and annoying by the third. So each Stray Stack is built from three kinds of pick.

  • Match

    The Match

    Squarely in your wheelhouse: a genre you love, a mood you asked for.

  • Stretch

    The Stretch

    Next door to what you love. Same mood, new neighbourhood.

  • Wild

    The Wildcard

    The one you’d never pick. You decide how wild it gets.

Try the wildness dial

Adventurous

Your wildcard wanders a couple of shelves over: new territory, familiar feelings.

Where your wildcard comes from, roughly
  • Genres you love 45%
  • Next door 33%
  • Somewhere new 22%
The Sniff Test

Pre-loved, never grubby

Every stray is checked by hand before it’s allowed near a box.

  • No smells. Smoke, must or mildew never ships.
  • No damage. Spine intact, every page present.
  • No highlighter crimes. A pencilled name is history; a neon chapter one is not.
  • Graded honestly. Like New or Very Good, unless you opt in to well-loved copies.
  • Bad Match Guarantee. Rate a book one wag within 30 days for $3 credit.
Plans

Pick a pile size

Every plan includes US shipping. Monthly or every other month. Change it whenever you like.

Prepay a year and save 10%. Or go every other month if your to-read pile is already a fire hazard.

Build your plan

Book Passport

Every stray carries a passport

Inside each cover is a little sticker with a code. Look it up to see where your book has been, read notes from readers before you, and stamp it when you pass it on.

Example journey
  1. Dayton, OH
    Rescued

    Friends of the Library sale. Graded Very Good.

  2. Austin, TX
    Reader 1 · five wags

    “cried on a plane, worth it”

  3. Portland, OR
    Reader 2 · four wags

    “read it in one sitting, sorry boss”

  4. Your city?
    Reader 3

    1,960 miles so far.

Where strays come from

Good books, given a second chapter

Unsold and unwanted books are pulped every year by the truckload. We get to the good ones first.

  • Library sales
  • Estate sales
  • Publisher overstock
  • Your trade-ins

Where our books come from

Gifts

Give someone a stray (or thirty-six)

Three, six or twelve months of surprises. They take the Sniff Test, we do the rest. Gifts never auto-renew.

Questions

The usual suspects

What if I already own one of the books?

Tell us what you’ve read: type titles, scan barcodes, or import your Goodreads or StoryGraph export. We never send a book on your list or a book you’ve already had from us. If one slips through, trade it in for credit.

How do skipping, pausing and cancelling work?

All online, from your account, no phone calls. Skip any upcoming box, pause for up to three months, or cancel in two clicks. Change anything before your renewal date and it applies to that box.

Are the books really in good condition?

Yes. Every copy passes our Sniff Test and is graded Like New or Very Good unless you opt in to well-loved copies. If a book arrives damaged, we replace it.

Can I choose the books?

Not individually, that’s the fun. You steer with genres, moods, hard nos and the wildness dial, and every rating teaches the matcher. If you want a peek, your clue cards appear in your account before the box ships.

Where do you ship?

Anywhere USPS delivers in the US, including Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, territories and APO/FPO addresses. Books travel by USPS Media Mail, which usually takes 2 to 8 business days.

All the questions